Why in news
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud’s home to attend a Ganesh Puja has triggered a political controversy and sparked divisions within the legal community
Some leaders from the Opposition and lawyers questioned the propriety of such a meeting, especially given the ongoing cases involving the government
The BJP and a section of legal voices dismissed the criticism as unwarranted, terming the event a private affair.
Restatement of Values of Judicial Life
A 16-point document adopted by the Supreme Court on May 7, 1997.
It provides guidelines for the conduct and behavior of Supreme Court and High Court judges.
Emphasizes maintaining the public’s faith in judicial impartiality.
Advises judges to remain aloof and conscious of their public image.
Aims to ensure justice is done and seen to be done.
Major Concerns About Judicial Integrity in India
Concerns about maintaining a proper, not overly cordial, relationship between judiciary and executive to preserve judicial independence.
Any actions or interactions that could lead to perceptions of compromised judicial impartiality or undue influence.
Public events involving judges may lead to gossip and affect the perception of judicial neutrality
Way Forward
Ensure judges and high officials adhere strictly to the Restatement of Values to uphold judicial integrity.
Reinforce the separation of powers between the judiciary and executive branches.
Handle sensitive interactions discreetly to avoid public speculation and maintain institutional credibility.
COMMENTS