U.S. Policy Shifts and Afghan Parallels
The U.S., under both Trump and Biden, is seen as having withdrawn support from Afghanistan, similar to its perceived actions in Ukraine.
Past U.S. actions, like the 2020 Doha Accords, favored the Taliban and contributed to the Afghan government's collapse.
The current Taliban regime has imposed severe restrictions, particularly on women, creating a stark contrast to the previous two decades.
The conference of exiles in Spain called the US and European withdrawal, a "Great Abandonment".
India's Evolving Engagement with the Taliban
India has been cautiously engaging with the Taliban, reopening a "technical mission" in Kabul.
India is considering expanding its presence in Kabul and potentially allowing a Taliban-appointed ambassador in Delhi.
India's motivations include pragmatism, maintaining strategic space in the region, and providing humanitarian aid.
Concerns and Criticisms of India's Approach
Critics argue that engaging with the Taliban risks losing credibility with Afghans who oppose the regime.
India's visa policies towards Afghan refugees have been criticized.
There are concerns about the Taliban's reliability as a strategic partner, given their history.
Recommendations for India's Future Policy
India should reconsider its current approach and rebuild relationships with those opposed to the Taliban.
India should advocate for women's rights in Afghanistan and provide platforms for exiled Afghan voices.
Maintain relationships with the current regime, but do not ignore the opposition.
COMMENTS