Accountability and Effectiveness
Consultancy firms like BCG, hired for strategic advice, lack "skin in the game," meaning they bear no responsibility for the outcomes of their recommendations.
If BSNL's performance doesn't improve after implementing BCG's strategies, BCG faces no consequences, while the taxpayer bears the risk.
This misalignment of incentives undermines the purpose of hiring external expertise, which should be to deliver tangible improvements and long-term viability.
The continued use of consultants, without accountability, create a cycle of needing more consultants.
Erosion of State Capacity and Expertise
Over-reliance on consultancies erodes the state's ability to innovate and manage its enterprises effectively.
Skills and knowledge gained by consultants are not transferred to public officials, leading to a loss of institutional knowledge and perpetuating dependency.
The proliferation of consultancy contracts reflects a crisis of confidence in the public sector's ability to govern itself.
This creates an unaccountable parallel bureaucracy of consultants who influence public policy without democratic oversight.
Conflicts of Interest and Public Service Mandate
Consultancy firms often serve multiple clients, including competitors and regulators, creating potential conflicts of interest.
Their profit-maximization approach may not align with the public service mandate of organizations like BSNL.
Cost-cutting measures may compromise essential services, particularly in underserved areas, undermining the organization's role as a public goods provider.
The focus is often on short term gains, rather than the long term public service goals.
Alternative Approaches
Investing in strengthening the internal capabilities of public sector institutions is a better alternative.
This involves recruiting and training talent, fostering innovation, and empowering employees.
Building internal expertise allows organizations to develop strategies aligned with their long-term goals and public service mandate.
Reclaiming strategic autonomy is crucial to reduce dependency on external consultants.
COMMENTS